• Get Started
    • Get Started on Zwift
    • Zwift Course Maps
    • How to Race on Zwift (Setup, Strategy, and More)
    • Links Every Zwifter Must Have
    • More “Get Started” Posts
  • Tips & Tricks
    • Kit Unlock Codes
    • Training & Nutrition
    • Racing
    • Zwift Hacks
  • Reference
    • How Zwift Works
    • Course Calendar
    • Smart Trainer Index
      • Top Wheel-On Trainers
      • Top Direct-Drive <$900
      • Top Direct-Drive >$900
      • Exhaustive Trainer List
    • Achievements & Unlocks
    • Frames & Wheels
    • Routes & Maps
      • Master List of Routes
      • Downloadable Watopia Map
      • Rebel Routes
    • Speed Tests
  • News
    • Events
    • Game Updates
  • Shop
Search
Logo
Logo
  • Get Started
    • Get Started on Zwift
    • Zwift Course Maps
    • How to Race on Zwift (Setup, Strategy, and More)
    • Links Every Zwifter Must Have
    • More “Get Started” Posts
  • Tips & Tricks
    • Kit Unlock Codes
    • Training & Nutrition
    • Racing
    • Zwift Hacks
  • Reference
    • How Zwift Works
    • Course Calendar
    • Smart Trainer Index
      • Top Wheel-On Trainers
      • Top Direct-Drive <$900
      • Top Direct-Drive >$900
      • Exhaustive Trainer List
    • Achievements & Unlocks
    • Frames & Wheels
    • Routes & Maps
      • Master List of Routes
      • Downloadable Watopia Map
      • Rebel Routes
    • Speed Tests
  • News
    • Events
    • Game Updates
  • Shop
More
    Sign in
    Welcome! Log into your account
    Forgot your password? Get help
    Privacy Policy
    Password recovery
    Recover your password
    A password will be e-mailed to you.
    Getting StartedHardware/EquipmentTrainers

    Smart Trainer vs Dumb Trainer – What’s the Difference?

    Eric Schlange
    By Eric Schlange
    October 16, 2020
    18

    Trainers can be organized into many different categories, but when it comes to Zwift, you’re either on a “smart” or a “classic” (or “dumb”) trainer.

    Smart Trainers

    Tacx Neo 2T

    A smart trainer’s resistance is controlled by Zwift. When the incline of the Zwift course changes, your resistance changes. You “feel” the hills. Additionally, a smart trainer will broadcast your power (and usually cadence) via ANT+ and Bluetooth. So those are the two key things smart trainers do which classic trainers do not: they detect your power (in watts), and change resistance on the hills.

    (Note: there are certain smart trainers which are not controllable by Zwift. They broadcast power, but do not change resistance on hills. We call these “non interactive” trainers, but they are rare nowadays.)

    Because smart trainers are complex electronic devices, they must either be plugged in or (in the case of a few trainers) powered by the watts you’re putting out.

    Popular top-quality smart trainers on Zwift include the Tacx Neo 2T, Wahoo Kickr, Wahoo Kickr Core, Saris H3. and Elite Direto XR.

    Check out our Smart Trainer Index for recommended trainers at different price levels.

    Dumb Trainers

    cycleops-pro
    CycleOps SuperMagneto

    A dumb trainer doesn’t talk to Zwift – hence the name “dumb.” You may be riding up and down hills on the Zwift course, but you’ll feel no difference in the resistance because Zwift has no way of talking to your trainer or changing its resistance. Dumb trainers also do not detect your power or cadence. All they do is provide steady resistance on your back wheel.

    Because of this lack of power detection, using a classic trainer on Zwift requires either a separate power meter (perhaps on your pedals, cranks, or wheel) or a speed sensor on your wheel and what Zwift calls “virtual power.” (Fair warning: virtual power users have a bit of a bad reputation on Zwift because their power is notoriously inaccurate, leading to “flyers” off the front in races.)

    Dumb trainers are super simple devices. No power to plug in – just attach it to your bike and go.

    Many serious Zwifters still ride classic trainers while using a power meter, because they already had both the trainer and the power meter before Zwift came along. This is a solid setup which produces accurate power readings. The only downsides are a lack of resistance changes on hills, and no ERG mode for workouts.

    What’s Best for Me?

    This is a question you have to answer yourself! If you have the money, going for a smart trainer will greatly enhance your Zwifting experience. The difference between riding Zwift on a classic trainer and riding it on a top of the line smart trainer is like night and day.

    That said, you gotta do what you gotta do. If you can only afford a classic trainer, then go with that! Perhaps in the future you can upgrade to a smart trainer, but at least you’ll be able to hop on Zwift and train right now without breaking your budget.

    Many Zwifters begin their indoor riding on a borrowed or used classic trainer, then take the plunge and purchase a nice smart trainer once they got hooked on Zwift.

    Related Posts

    Facebook
    Twitter
    Pinterest
    ReddIt
      Eric Schlange
      Eric Schlangehttp://www.zwiftinsider.com
      Eric runs Zwift Insider in his spare time when he isn't on the bike or managing various business interests. He lives in Northern California with his beautiful wife, two kids and dog. Follow on Strava

      18 COMMENTS

      Subscribe
      Log in using
      Notify of
      guest
      Log in using
      guest
      18 Comments
      oldest
      newest most voted
      Inline Feedbacks
      View all comments
      Mike
      Mike
      1 year ago

      Hi Eric, as a newbie to zwift your articles are really useful in understanding the delights, details and nuances of Zwifting. On seeing this article I hoped you might answer a question that has been going through my mind regarding the difference between smart trainers and what you referred to as non- interactive trainers. So I have one of these, broadcasting power and cadence, and ride with a couple of friends who have smart trainers. Comparing power outputs when riding together, our watts are comparable but when the hills arrive they suffer the increase in resistance whilst I don’t, I… Read more »

      2
      Reply
      Eric Schlange
      Author
      Top Member
      Eric Schlange(@eschlange)
      1 year ago
      Reply to  Mike

      Hi Mike, I’d say it doesn’t give you any advantage. In fact, I’d say the vast majority of the time you’re at a disadvantage, since you have to respond in an unintuitive way in order to keep up on the climbs! Smart trainer users naturally go harder on climbs, just like outside. But you have to up your cadence and/or shift to a harder gear in order to increase your wattage on the climbs – both actions which riders do NOT do when they hit an uphill IRL! The only time it’s an advantage, I think, is if the smart… Read more »

      4
      Reply
      Mike
      Mike
      1 year ago
      Reply to  Eric Schlange

      Hi Eric, thought I’d read the other post you gave the link to before replying and it certainly adds to this question. At the end of the day it’s about the wattage each rider puts up to achieve a given speed on any particular section of a course, uphill, flat or down. Assuming two riders of equal weight and fpt, one on smart and one on a non- interactive trainer, on hitting a hill the smart rider will increase effort but may have to shift down to stop going into the red too early or at all and to maintain… Read more »

      0
      Reply
      Rick Steiger
      Rick Steiger
      1 year ago

      I do continue to see “dumb trainer” riders taking the jerseys on Zwift jersey segments ex; Green jerseys, KOM jerseys and orange jerseys. Mostly the times recorded are insanely fast or “unrealistic”. Wish Zwift would give them their own leaderboard

      0
      Reply
      Benjamin
      Benjamin(@benjamin_pitt)
      1 year ago
      Reply to  Rick Steiger

      I think some of the “unrealistic” times are also from riders riding in “stat together” and getting launched at 60kmh to catch up.

      0
      Reply
      andre
      andre
      1 year ago

      Hi Eric, another great article, I starting zwifting on a dumb trainer but the lack of resistance was really boring and led me to, first bought a wheel on smart trainer, and later a direct drive, and this was a really gamer changer on my training, improved a lot after this, seeing my fitness and my irl rides gain some solid achievements. Keep up the good work!

      0
      Reply
      dan
      dan
      1 year ago

      ZP shouldnt be allowed in races; period – just have their own hackfest of pretenders

      2
      Reply
      Nick
      Nick
      1 year ago

      One thing about “dumb” trainers – they are usually pretty solid and stable.I have a Kurt Kinetic Rock and Roll, so I can get out of the saddle with no trouble, bike has lateral movement on trainer, whereas I’m not sure smart trainers have this.

      2
      Reply
      Tim
      Tim
      1 year ago

      I have borrowed friends smart trainers both wheel on and off, I bought a dumb trainer and have got going for $275 using a cadence/speed sensor. As mentioned I’d see the point of power metre and dumb trainer in temperate climates but if I lived somewhere with long cold winters I’d probably skip to a smart bike to limit the wear on the real bike.

      0
      Reply
      Henrik Funch
      Henrik Funch
      1 year ago

      Also,… If you do structured intervals on Zwift a smart trainer behaves exactly like a ‘dumb’ trainer. Ie, there is no variable resistance, you just have to hit your watt numbers and intervals….. So if you mainly do training plans and intervals there is no reason to go for a ‘smart’ trainer.

      1
      Reply
      Eric Schlange
      Author
      Top Member
      Eric Schlange(@eschlange)
      1 year ago
      Reply to  Henrik Funch

      That’s not true. Smart trainers let you do workouts in ERG mode, where they force you to hold the prescribed wattage. Dumb trainers make you manage that wattage yourself, and you’ll never be as precise as an ERG mode effort.

      0
      Reply
      Henrik Funch
      Henrik Funch
      1 year ago
      Reply to  Eric Schlange

      Sorry, I should have been more precise. I was not addressing erg mode, but structured intervals like ‘5x4min at 225watt’…. Where you yourself manage your cadence and try to hit the required watt numbers, or thereabouts …. Some days you struggle with 225watt, but 220 watts is ok, some days 225watt is easy and you can push 230watt, as long as you hit suitable interval around 225watt you’re fine training wise …. ERG mode is a different beast, it forces you to do 225watt no matter what.

      1
      Reply
      Giuseppe
      Giuseppe
      1 year ago
      Reply to  Eric Schlange

      Erg mode is over rated.No such yhing in real life cycling outdoors or traing or racing outdoors.

      0
      Reply
      Lewis
      Lewis
      1 year ago
      Reply to  Giuseppe

      It’s supposed to help you with workouts. Zwift isn’t real-life.

      0
      Reply
      Joe
      Joe
      1 year ago

      Eric, I would like to clarify one part of the dumb trainer experience. I ride on one and have cadence and wheel speed sensors on my bike. Zwift easily connects to them and I have no trouble with my cadence showing up in the game. The program uses an algorithm to determine my watts based on wheel speed and cadence. Then converts that to mph based on watts and incline. I believe the watts are not 100% accurate but they should be close. I ride against myself so if I improve my watts, that means I’m getting faster/stronger. Also, I… Read more »

      1
      Reply
      Giuseppe
      Giuseppe
      1 year ago
      Reply to  Joe

      @Joe. Exactly. I used a KK dumb trainer w virtual power and cadence on Zwift znd Trainer Road for a couple of years. It was awesome. In game experience in Zwift was about 80% as fun as w a smart trsiner I now use. I still love the feel of my “dumb” KK trainer and do go back to it at times. Dont automatically believe the repeated hype about “…absolutely having to have a smart trainer, otherwise Zwift will be absolutely boring…

      0
      Reply
      stephen
      stephen
      1 year ago

      Eric, first of all thanks for all of your work! General question. I have a wahoo kickr and also garmin vector power pedals. The pedals “give me” around an extra 5-10 watts, I believe the difference is down to the loss via the drive train so numbers are likely accurate. Question is for racing is it poor form to use the garmin vector pedals to gain these extra few watts and use the smart trainer for training. I use the pedals outside so would be useful to have correlating data but feel right thing is possibly to stick with the… Read more »

      0
      Reply
      Eric Schlange
      Author
      Top Member
      Eric Schlange(@eschlange)
      1 year ago
      Reply to  stephen

      I don’t think it’s bad form. Some might disagree. And I think in the big high-level Zwift racers, riders are required to use their trainer as their power source, with pedals, etc as a secondary source just to show the trainer power is legit.

      I’m in the same boat as you – I use pedal power meters outdoors, and want my numbers to match up. So I use my pedals as my primary source. (I also can’t help but thing pedal-based power meters with actual strain gauges are more accurate than power estimated from belt speed…)

      1
      Reply
      wpdiscuz   wpDiscuz

      Free Zwift Trial

      Create Account

      Newest Featured Posts

      Elite’s Best Gets Better: Justo Direct Drive Trainer Review

      Trainers

      Zwift Chartgeist, Volume 3

      How Zwift Works

      Chasing Yellow Event Series Announced

      Events

      Support This Site

      Contribute a post, shop through us, make a donation, advertise on this site. See how you can support Zwift Insider!

      This community-driven site is maintained by Eric Schlange and a team of Zwift enthusiasts. Zwift Insider is independent of Zwift corporate (www.zwift.com), although Zwift does provide funding to help defray site costs.

      This site contains affiliate links to Amazon, Wahoo, and other brands. Zwift Insider makes a small commission on purchases made from these links, so please shop through them to support our efforts.

      Terms of Use/DMCA Copyright Policy

      Privacy Policy

      [email protected]

      Latest articles

      Elite’s Best Gets Better: Justo Direct Drive Trainer Review

      Notable Zwift Events for the Weekend of July 2-3

      Unbound Home Triathlons (Nowhere Fast Episode 38)

      Popular Categories

      • Racing869
      • News695
      • Training & Nutrition563
      • Interviews430
      • Events377
      • Routes & Maps288
      18
      0
      Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
      ()
      x
      | Reply
      Comment Author Info
      :wpds_smile::wpds_grin::wpds_wink::wpds_mrgreen::wpds_neutral::wpds_twisted::wpds_arrow::wpds_shock::wpds_unamused::wpds_cool::wpds_evil::wpds_oops::wpds_razz::wpds_roll::wpds_cry::wpds_eek::wpds_lol::wpds_mad::wpds_sad::wpds_exclamation::wpds_question::wpds_idea::wpds_hmm::wpds_beg::wpds_whew::wpds_chuckle::wpds_silly::wpds_envy::wpds_shutmouth:
      You are going to send email to

      Move Comment


    • Related Posts