Facebook Instagram Twitter Youtube
  • Get Started
    • Create Zwift Account
    • How To Get Started On Zwift
    • Zwift Course Maps
    • How to Race on Zwift (Setup, Strategy, and More)
    • Women’s Racing on Zwift
    • Links Every Zwifter Must Have
    • More “Get Started” Posts
  • Tips & Tricks
    • Training & Nutrition
    • Racing
    • Zwift Hacks
  • Reference
    • How Zwift Works
    • Course Calendar
    • RoboPacer Calendar
    • Climb Portal Calendar
    • Upcoming Events
    • Game Updates
    • Smart Trainer Index
      • Current Models
      • Exhaustive Trainer List
    • Achievements & Unlocks
      • XP Basics for Riders
      • XP Basics for Runners
      • Kit Unlock Codes
      • Master List of Badges
    • Frames & Wheels
    • Routes & Maps
      • Master List: Routes
      • Master List: Climb Portal
      • Master List: KOMs
      • Master List: Sprints
      • Master List: Rebel Routes
      • Downloadable Watopia Map
      • Printable List of Routes by Difficulty
    • Speed Tests
    • Tiny Races
  • Women
    • Race Calendar
    • Why race?
    • Women’s Teams
    • Racer Spotlights
    • More Women’s Racing posts
  • Shop
    • Watopia Map and Other Posters
    • ZI Indoor Cycling Kit
Search
Logo
Logo
  • Get Started
    • Create Zwift Account
    • How To Get Started On Zwift
    • Zwift Course Maps
    • How to Race on Zwift (Setup, Strategy, and More)
    • Women’s Racing on Zwift
    • Links Every Zwifter Must Have
    • More “Get Started” Posts
  • Tips & Tricks
    • Training & Nutrition
    • Racing
    • Zwift Hacks
  • Reference
    • How Zwift Works
    • Course Calendar
    • RoboPacer Calendar
    • Climb Portal Calendar
    • Upcoming Events
    • Game Updates
    • Smart Trainer Index
      • Current Models
      • Exhaustive Trainer List
    • Achievements & Unlocks
      • XP Basics for Riders
      • XP Basics for Runners
      • Kit Unlock Codes
      • Master List of Badges
    • Frames & Wheels
    • Routes & Maps
      • Master List: Routes
      • Master List: Climb Portal
      • Master List: KOMs
      • Master List: Sprints
      • Master List: Rebel Routes
      • Downloadable Watopia Map
      • Printable List of Routes by Difficulty
    • Speed Tests
    • Tiny Races
  • Women
    • Race Calendar
    • Why race?
    • Women’s Teams
    • Racer Spotlights
    • More Women’s Racing posts
  • Shop
    • Watopia Map and Other Posters
    • ZI Indoor Cycling Kit
More
    Hardware/Equipment

    Debunking ANT+ Myths and Experimenting with USB Stick Placement

    Greg Hilton
    By Greg Hilton
    February 27, 2021
    LAST UPDATED February 27, 2021
    55

    Much has already been written about reducing ANT+ interference, including this Zwift Insider article. Conventional wisdom and many forum and Facebook user groups advocate placing your ANT+ dongle close to the trainer. Others are adamant that a powered USB hub is the only answer.

    USB Port and Power Draw

    There are also numerous suggestions on the ‘net that your USB port needs to deliver 500ma to prevent dropouts. So I decided to look into that! Using the free version of USBDeview from nirsoft.net, I noted that although my ports can deliver 500mA, neither of my two ANT+ devices ever draw more than 100mA.

    I plugged the ant+ stick into the port shown below as delivering 500mA to a webcam and the power dropped to 100mA on that port.

    I checked this with a very well respected Zwift PC guru who gets very clean ANT+ signals and he confirmed the same on his ports.

    As a third test, Eric (Zwift Insider editor) ran the test on his own system. Same results – all ANT+ sticks were drawing 100mA:

    A sample size of only three, but seems pretty solid evidence that 100mA draw is absolutely fine.

    ANT+ Dongle Positioning

    Next, it was time to try a number of varying positions for my ANT+ adapters. The results were surprising!

    The dongles used in these tests were the Anself USB ANT+ stick and Garmin USB ANT+ stick (see Recommended ANT+ Sticks for Zwift).

    The four positions I tried are shown in the picture below. All analysis was done with the excellent Zwiftalizer – The Logfile Analyzer for Zwift. Ideally, we want zero searches and as few avg rxfails as possible.

    Directly into the PC – Position 1

    First off I plugged one ANT+ adapter directly into the PC. As expected this gave the worst results as the PC is in front of my bike. Although not dreadful, there were 5 times that the devices tried to repair, and over 51% fails.

    • Anself direct into PC (pos 1)
    • Garmin direct into PC (pos 1)

    Under the trainer – Position 2

    I next tried to position the stick just under the KICKR v5.

    The Garmin had less searches than the Anself, but more fails. All tests were done in the same position, same USB port, and same extension cable.

    • Anself behind trainer
    • Garmin behind trainer

    Under the bottom bracket – Position 3

    Moving the dingles forward seemed to improve things a little, still with one search for the KICKR but less Avg fails:

    • Anself under bottom bracket (pos 3)
    • Garmin under bottom bracket (pos 3)

    Under the front wheel – Position 4

    Since moving the adapter forwards improved the signal, I took it even further forwards and placed it just under the front wheel. So further away from the KICKR, but this got the best results yet!

    The Garmin doesn’t perform as well as the Anself in this position, which is strange as the pedals are very close to the ant+ adapter now.

    • Anself under front wheel (pos 4)
    • Garmin under front wheel (pos 4)

    Powered USB Hub (Position 4)

    • Anself in powered USB hub (pos 4)
    • Garmin in powered USB hub (pos 4)

    ANT+ Adapter raised off the floor

    I also raised the Ansell off the floor in Position 4, and looped it over a cardboard box (to try and minimise any further interference. This actually made the signal worse for me.

    Summary Table and Conclusions

    Here is a summary including the averaging of the searches and RXfails for each adapter in each of the 4 positions. It’s clear that position 4 gets the lowest avg fails and searches for the Anself, whereas the Garmin appears to prefer position 3. It is also interesting, that for me, the powered USB hub made no huge improvement to a quality shielded USB extension cable placed in the appropriate position.

    It’s also interesting to note that the Anself performs better than the Garmin in terms of avg fails, despite being less than half the price! (See them on Amazon here: Anself USB ANT+ stick / Garmin USB ANT+ stick).

    In large group rides

    I tried position 4 with the Anself in a Tour De Zwift catchup ride with 250+ people and I’m confident that it’s the best position now for me.

    Note: the Wahoo KICKR doesn’t have the ability to turn off the standard ANT+ unlike the Tacx NEO, so the dual ANT and FEC creating the small interference troughs shown at regular intervals.

    I hope this helps you in your quest to get a rock-solid ANT+ signal to your PC!

    Questions or Comments?

    Share below!

    Related Posts

    Facebook
    Twitter
    Pinterest
    ReddIt
      Greg Hilton
      Greg Hilton
      Greg lives in Leeds, UK and has been interested in sport, technology and gadgets since his teenage years. He joined the Zwift beta in January 2015 and uses Zwift for workouts, recovery rides and the occasional race. It really was and still is a revolution in indoor training in his eyes! Last year Greg tried out Triathlon for the first time and really enjoyed it so fellow Zwifters may see him on the bike or treadmill. Ride on!

      55 COMMENTS

      Subscribe
      Notify of
      guest

      guest

      55 Comments
      Oldest
      Newest Most Voted
      Inline Feedbacks
      View all comments
      wpdiscuz   wpDiscuz

      Get Started on Zwift

      Sign Up (Free Trial)
      Buy Zwift Ride
      Buy KICKR CORE One
      Read More...

      Newest Featured Posts

      Garmin Releases Tacx Alpine Gradient Simulator

      Hardware/Equipment

      All About the New DT Swiss Wheels in Zwift

      Speed Tests

      Support This Site

      Write a post, shop through us, donate or advertise. Learn more

      NEWSLETTER SIGNUP

      Zwift tips and news every 2 weeks! Click to subscribe.

      More Posts

      “Allez Allez Allez!” ZRacing Series Details

      Events

      Zwift RoboPacer Cycling Route Schedule

      How Zwift Works

      Elite Announces New Zwift-Ready Avanti and Rivo Trainers

      Trainers

      Zwift Charts: Rate of New Road Construction from 2015 to Present

      Game Updates

      This community-driven site is maintained by Eric Schlange and a team of Zwift enthusiasts. Zwift Insider is independent of Zwift corporate (www.zwift.com), although Zwift does provide funding to help defray site costs.

      This site contains affiliate links to Amazon, Wahoo, and other brands. Zwift Insider makes a small commission on purchases made from these links, so please shop through them to support our efforts.

      Terms of Use/DMCA Copyright Policy

      Privacy Policy | Privacy Consent

      [email protected]

      Latest articles

      Garmin Releases Tacx Alpine Gradient Simulator

      Notable Zwift Events for the Weekend of June 28-29

      All About the New DT Swiss Wheels in Zwift

      Popular Categories

      • Racing1501
      • Events1007
      • News833
      • Training & Nutrition710
      • Interviews562
      • Routes & Maps442
      55
      0
      Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
      ()
      x
      | Reply
      Comment Author Info
      :wpds_smile::wpds_grin::wpds_wink::wpds_mrgreen::wpds_neutral::wpds_twisted::wpds_arrow::wpds_shock::wpds_unamused::wpds_cool::wpds_evil::wpds_oops::wpds_razz::wpds_roll::wpds_cry::wpds_eek::wpds_lol::wpds_mad::wpds_sad::wpds_exclamation::wpds_question::wpds_idea::wpds_hmm::wpds_beg::wpds_whew::wpds_chuckle::wpds_silly::wpds_envy::wpds_shutmouth:
      ‹ Back to Categories
      You are going to send email to

      Move Comment

    • Related Posts