• Get Started
    • Get Started on Zwift
    • Zwift Course Maps
    • How to Race on Zwift (Setup, Strategy, and More)
    • Links Every Zwifter Must Have
    • More “Get Started” Posts
  • Tips & Tricks
    • Kit Unlock Codes
    • Training & Nutrition
    • Racing
    • Zwift Hacks
  • Reference
    • How Zwift Works
    • Course Calendar
    • RoboPacer Calendar
    • Smart Trainer Index
      • Top Wheel-On Trainers
      • Top Direct-Drive <$900
      • Top Direct-Drive >$900
      • Exhaustive Trainer List
    • Achievements & Unlocks
    • Frames & Wheels
    • Routes & Maps
      • Master List of Routes
      • Master List of KOMs
      • Master List of Sprints
      • Downloadable Watopia Map
      • Rebel Routes
    • Speed Tests
  • News
    • Events
    • Game Updates
  • Shop
Search
Logo
Logo
  • Get Started
    • Get Started on Zwift
    • Zwift Course Maps
    • How to Race on Zwift (Setup, Strategy, and More)
    • Links Every Zwifter Must Have
    • More “Get Started” Posts
  • Tips & Tricks
    • Kit Unlock Codes
    • Training & Nutrition
    • Racing
    • Zwift Hacks
  • Reference
    • How Zwift Works
    • Course Calendar
    • RoboPacer Calendar
    • Smart Trainer Index
      • Top Wheel-On Trainers
      • Top Direct-Drive <$900
      • Top Direct-Drive >$900
      • Exhaustive Trainer List
    • Achievements & Unlocks
    • Frames & Wheels
    • Routes & Maps
      • Master List of Routes
      • Master List of KOMs
      • Master List of Sprints
      • Downloadable Watopia Map
      • Rebel Routes
    • Speed Tests
  • News
    • Events
    • Game Updates
  • Shop
More
    Sign in
    Welcome! Log into your account
    Forgot your password? Get help
    Privacy Policy
    Password recovery
    Recover your password
    A password will be e-mailed to you.
    News

    The Fence: Where It Went, When It Will Return, and Why It’s Needed

    Eric Schlange
    By Eric Schlange
    March 13, 2020
    148

    If you participate in group rides on Zwift, you’ve probably noticed that the fence hasn’t been in use for the past few weeks. What happened, and is the fence returning? We reached out to Zwift HQ for answers!

    Intro to the Fence

    The fence’s functionality is quite simple from an end-user’s perspective. The ride leader is able to set how far ahead of themselves the fence appears (default options are 2 seconds, 5 seconds, or 10 seconds). They can also turn the fence off.

    If you are far enough behind the fence you won’t see it at all, but if you get close enough you’ll see the red “wall.” Ride through the fence and a countdown warning pops up telling you to return to the group within 1 minute.

    • The fence is visible if you are close enough
    • Ride through the fence and you’ll get this warning and countdown
    • Here is what ride leaders see for fence controls and stats

    If you don’t return to the group within a minute you are automatically booted from the ride.

    The Broken Fence

    On February 20th, 2020, ride leaders were informed that Zwift was disabling the fence immediately. Here is what Zwift said about the reasons for disabling the fence:

    Why did we turn off the fence?
    In certain situations and conditions, a non-trivial number of users were being removed from events, even though they were well behind the fence or the leader. In other words, even though some users were riding well, they were still getting removed. Since this is not a good experience for those users, we temporarily removed the fence feature from group rides.

    Any Zwifters who regularly participate in group rides can confirm the truth of what Zwift said – there were definitely riders getting booted by the fence even though they were staying behind it. And nobody wants that!

    The fence still exists in-game, it’s just disabled for all events. A few events, in fact, have accidentally had the fence enabled in recent days! But this isn’t Zwift testing anything – it’s just an event that wasn’t quite set up properly.

    When Will the Fence Return?

    This is the question many Zwifters and especially ride leaders are asking. Here’s what Zwift told us yesterday:

    We have tracked down a few issues that we feel were impacting event fences and fixed those issues. We’ve also added telemetry specifically for fenced events to get more data if new issues arise. We will be turning the fence back on for select rides with the upcoming game release scheduled for the end of March.

    ZHQ will be actively monitoring the rides to evaluate the fixes we’ve put in place. Once we are confident that we’ve solved the issues, the fence will be made available to all rides that wish to use it.

    So that’s good news: Zwift has obviously prioritized fixing the fence, and it looks like we’ll see it when the next update arrives at the end of this month.

    Do We Need the Fence?

    The fence being turned off has led to discussions within the community about whether or not the fence is needed. Some riders like the “freedom” of no fences, while others like the more controlled groups created by the fence. Who’s right? Do we need a fence?

    To be sure, some group rides don’t need a fence: long events like Zwift centuries, for example, typically work better if groups are allowed to form naturally. And a small number of group rides use categories as pace groups, allowing riders to select the pace they want to ride.

    That said, group ride leaders are overwhelmingly in favor of bringing the fence back. Why? Because without it, group rides get strung out, gaps form, and someone will inevitably complain that the pace is too high even though they’re riding off the front well ahead of the leader’s group.

    Here’s a screenshot of me leading this morning’s Pacific Sprintapalooza ride. As you can see, our group was rather small (64 riders), and it routinely split, with half the group riding several seconds ahead. This isn’t what we want for a ride like Sprintapalooza, where the intent is to spin together between group sprint efforts.

    In this morning’s ride, the front group was pretty good about returning to the beacon group when I messaged and asked them to ease up and join us. But that’s not always the case, and I would much rather have the group just stay together without constant messaging. (Ride leaders prefer to use their messages to provide encouragement and banter, not to corral those off the front.)

    With the fence enabled, group rides stay together as a pack. With it turned off, group rides split into multiple pace groups. For some rides that’s ok – for others it is not. Simple as that!

    Your Thoughts

    Have you missed the fence, or are you happy it’s gone? How can ride leaders best control their rides in the absence of a fence? Please share your thoughts below!

    Related Posts

    Facebook
    Twitter
    Pinterest
    ReddIt
      Eric Schlange
      Eric Schlangehttp://www.zwiftinsider.com
      Eric runs Zwift Insider in his spare time when he isn't on the bike or managing various business interests. He lives in Northern California with his beautiful wife, two kids and dog. Follow on Strava

      148 COMMENTS

      Subscribe
      Connect with
      Notify of
      guest

      Connect with
      guest

      148 Comments
      Oldest
      Newest Most Voted
      Inline Feedbacks
      View all comments
      Rick Mosher
      Rick Mosher
      3 years ago

      When are we getting levels 50 – 100 ?

      -20
      Reply
      Stephen Douglas
      Stephen Douglas
      3 years ago

      I lead the two PRTR rides: Wednesday’s 2 w/kg ride and the Thursday progressive ride. For the 2 w/kg ride I’d REALLY like to have the fence back. As the article states, the lower paced rides without a fence will naturally split into multiple pace groups, and a ridership of 200 riders will typically leave a bunch of 50 or less around the yellow beacon. This is all fine and good and I’m all for people riding at their preferred pace, but it generates quite a bit of discontent among those that are staying with the yellow beacon group. If… Read more »

      13
      Reply
      Eric Schlange
      Author
      Top Member
      Eric Schlange(@eschlange)
      3 years ago
      Reply to  Stephen Douglas

      Yes, faster rides definitely need the fence less! It seems like the cutoff is probably around 3 w/kg. Below that and you’ll get flyers, but above that and flyers will most get reeled back in.

      4
      Reply
      Chip
      Chip
      3 years ago
      Reply to  Stephen Douglas

      Agree mostly but in the faster rides, certain spots like top of hills excetra cause a yo-yo effect that leads to a ton more work for those in the back to catch back on. Of course, that’s like any outdoor ride and I’m biased as the sweep, but just sayin. 🙂 And Stephen is the best I’ve seen at watching the group and providing well timed appropriate reminders to those in front.

      0
      Reply
      Donald ( GH70) Silas
      Donald ( GH70) Silas
      3 years ago

      Hi Eric, If there is a stated pace in a ride announcement, there should be a fence control at the stated pace. Group energy is contagious. I’m like an animal, when a rider speeds up or attacks, I can’t help chasing. Or we start elbowing for the pull and suddenly we are flying. We just can’t help influencing each other to go faster. It’s a kind insanity since it will ALWAYS happen without the sanity of this limitation. We need the fence.

      15
      Reply
      Eric Schlange
      Author
      Top Member
      Eric Schlange(@eschlange)
      3 years ago
      Reply to  Donald ( GH70) Silas

      Agreed! It takes a lot of discipline and focus, even for experienced Zwifters, to hang with the beacon on a slower-paced group ride. It’s easy to get swept up in a group that is slowly outpacing the leader.

      1
      Reply
      Mark Mckie
      Mark Mckie
      3 years ago

      Why do so many zwifters treat group rides as a race? If you want to be fastest then enter a race. Group rides are aimed at set speeds/power to ensure the group can stay together. If all zwifters understood this we would not need a fence at all.

      23
      Reply
      Eric Schlange
      Author
      Top Member
      Eric Schlange(@eschlange)
      3 years ago
      Reply to  Mark Mckie

      I think most Zwifters aren’t treating them as a race – but they’re riding just a bit harder than they should, and they drift off the front. It takes focus to stay with the beacon, when there are enough riders spinning along at a pace just slightly higher.

      That said–we’re cyclists! So there’s almost always some level of competition going on. I don’t think you can get away from that entirely, so something like the fence is needed to control the effects of our humanity. 😀

      7
      Reply
      Brian
      Brian
      3 years ago
      Reply to  Eric Schlange

      I found one ride “Back to Basics” that week after week has flyers that would do 4.0 w/kg. The problem is because of the nature of that ride, a lot of newbies and people that aren’t experiences just follow the wheel in front of them until their heart explodes, then they complain about the leader having too high of a pace. I came to the conclusion that these guys were using it for their own race since most group rides are on Zwiftpower. So I think there are some that are guilty of using them as their own race…but that… Read more »

      0
      Reply
      Gerrie Delport
      Gerrie Delport(@gerriedelport)
      3 years ago
      Reply to  Mark Mckie

      And why do Zwifters race in lower categories when they need a recovery “ride”. Races are for racing and group rides is for fun and social interaction.

      25
      Reply
      Darin Boyd
      Darin Boyd
      3 years ago

      I’m pretty vocally anti-fence in general, though there are certain rides, especially smaller ones where it really helps. I think its unnecessary, if not actually detrimental to rides of more than say 150 (honestly I think 100). You can only see the closest 100 or so riders to you anyway and in my experience once you let some flyers go off the front, a good majority group forms around the beacon and all is well. If you have a fence, then there always seems to be those wannabe flyers constantly pushing the limits an generally disrupting the group from settling… Read more »

      -12
      Reply
      Sage Koh aka S. Koh on zwift
      Sage Koh aka S. Koh on zwift
      3 years ago
      Reply to  Darin Boyd

      If a ride is posted at 2 wpk, then why do some feel the need to surge ahead at 3.0 or 3.5 wpk? One word…EGO. If you feel the need to ride fast, find a fast ride. People will always chase and that in itself will keep the ride unsettled. If there is a fence, the wannabe flyer will be stopped. If you keep cruising through the fence, it means you are on the wrong ride. Discipline is lacking for those who feel the need to fly off the front. I can tear the legs off of most people, but… Read more »

      20
      Reply
      Harri Toivonen
      Harri Toivonen
      3 years ago
      Reply to  Sage Koh aka S. Koh on zwift

      I think this example was a little over pointed! We have also climbing group rides where the riders have different weight (can easily be 20kg difference) and so they are riding a little bit different pace naturally during flat and climbs. However, they can ride in same group ride but 10s fence is much too restrictive.

      0
      Reply
      Nita
      Nita
      2 years ago
      Reply to  Darin Boyd

      I think it contradicts to the meaning of the posted w/kg. If you know that you can and want to ride higher the posted w/kg, then join the higher w/kg. Why join a lesser w/kg? is it so you can feel good that you can ride way faster than everyone else in the group? Is it because if you don’t want to join the faster group because you don’t want to the one that got dropped all the time? That’s what I always wonder. What’s the point of joining a group ride with specific w/kg, but you want to ride… Read more »

      1
      Reply
      Darren Bernard
      Darren Bernard
      3 years ago

      I miss the fence! I like to ride at the advertised pace and all it takes is one or two riders to string out the whole group. There are many rides that allow you to faster if you are too strong or you can help all the dropped riders by sweeping. My least favorite thing is the griping about flyers with no fence! Just let them go and ride with the lead. That’s where all the fun is happening anyway!

      1
      Reply
      Luke
      Luke
      3 years ago

      Just did a ride last night. My wife and I ride side by side trainers. We both have a FTP w/k of about 3.1 or so. So we are decent riders and have been on Zwift for years and know the deal with most everything. We understand how weight affects things, drafting, double draft…. all that stuff. The ride was advertised at 2.0-2.5 which we take to mean 2.5 out the gate and hold it. They always seem to push the upper limit. No big deal. The fence was off obviously and riders went off the front like they normally… Read more »

      5
      Reply
      Eric Schlange
      Author
      Top Member
      Eric Schlange(@eschlange)
      3 years ago
      Reply to  Luke

      I’d say double draft should help in her situation, as long as riders aren’t pushing the pace too much at the front. Comparing two rides where the group’s riders are holding the same effort level, the double draft ride should be easier to “sit in” with.

      But if the pace is too high and she gets gapped, double draft definitely does NOT help, because the group travels faster with double draft, which means it’s harder to grab back on if you get dropped.

      1
      Reply
      Stacey Rich
      Active Member
      Stacey Rich(@stacey_rich)
      3 years ago
      Reply to  Luke

      I am a light rider – usually the lightest on a group ride and my 15 second power is lower than their 20 min – and I can tell you the double draft is a HUGE problem for me on flats. I always check the leader’s weight on ZP ahead so I know how fast I will need to go to keep up at the ‘stated’ pace ((their weight x the high end of the stated pace ) / my weight ) and add +0.5 wkg), but being in the pack around the leader is like a vortex, and I… Read more »

      6
      Reply
      Sage Koh
      Sage Koh
      3 years ago
      Reply to  Stacey Rich

      You’re doing the right thing, stay at the front right from the start so if you slow down for any reason, you wont get dropped from the group and have to really struggle to get back. Surf the peloton at the front and mitigate getting dropped from the group completely.

      1
      Reply
      Nita
      Nita
      2 years ago
      Reply to  Stacey Rich

      I agree with you. I’m pretty light rider (5.2/108 lbs). I really don’t like riding around the leader. I felt the surge almost all the time. I usually ended up riding on w/kg than people around me if I ride around the leader. So I prefer to ride way in the front of the leader because I can ride the prescribe w/kg a lot better. And I personally don’t like riding in the blob (middle and back peloton). People are constantly jostling around each other. And as soon as they saw someone pass them, they surge. As much as there… Read more »

      0
      Reply
      Deb
      Deb
      3 years ago
      Reply to  Luke

      This has been my exact same struggle for the past three weeks. Advertising of a 2.5 w/kg ride means 2.8-3.0 for my 132 lb body. I see the leaders pushing above, too. If a gap forms at the start, I’ve had to push over 4.0 for several minutes to latch on. Frustrating.

      4
      Reply
      Umsiukas
      Umsiukas
      3 years ago

      Hi Eric
      Not fence related
      I’m making a return to cyclo Cross
      Next year and I’m looking for a zwifting training partner
      Advice please
      Daz

      -4
      Reply
      Umsiukas
      Umsiukas
      3 years ago
      Reply to  Umsiukas

      This is my avatar next to the above comment, but I did not post it. How come?

      -1
      Reply
      Mats Aadde
      Mats Aadde(@matsaadde)
      3 years ago

      As a rider I think it would be ok to omitt the fence in group rides with over say 200 participants, where some people will find their own groups but there will still be enough riders for a solid blob round the Ride Leader.
      Furthermore it’s not a great solution to just cancel the ride for those who fry on the fence. Better to pop them back in the ride behind the blob I think.

      10
      Reply
      MikeW
      MikeW
      3 years ago
      Reply to  Mats Aadde

      Teleporting the riders to the back of the blob is a great idea. Not as harsh but just as effective.

      8
      Reply
      Richard M Treadway
      Richard M Treadway
      3 years ago
      Reply to  Mats Aadde

      That’s a great idea.

      0
      Reply
      Nita
      Nita
      2 years ago
      Reply to  Mats Aadde

      That’s a great idea. Some people probably don’t mean it (at least I did. Didn’t know what the count down and I wasn’t close to the fence). But it would be hilarious for the fliers. Keep going off the fence and get spit back to the back of the group. Then go upfront again, get spit off again.. like a hamster wheel. Maybe that should teach them a lesson..

      1
      Reply
      Luke
      Luke
      3 years ago

      I have seen the idea for people who do not like a fence as an option to not have a predetermined route. The ride leader chooses and if you are way off the front, well, you get lost. Just like in real life. There are some logistics to work out here like the time you have to react to turns. Maybe if you are within a certain distance of the leader you stick to them, who know, but I kind of like that idea. It is a fence sort of without actually having a fence. If they did it and… Read more »

      2
      Reply
      Bob Roberts
      Bob Roberts
      3 years ago

      Bring Back the Fence!! The fence brings order to chaos. I feel sorry for our amazing ride leaders because they put so much time into organising a fantastic group ride experience and end up having to type “ease front” every 60 seconds. Front think “what’s the problem?” But they don’t realise that others try to keep up with them, and the average speed of the group (and power) incrementally lifts; humans are social pack animals, like sheep. This increase makes it very difficult for riders in the lower quartile of power for the group, as they regularly get dropped and… Read more »

      21
      Reply
      Jer Walker
      Active Member
      Jer Walker(@jerwalker)
      3 years ago

      I like the concept of your Sprintapalooza ride. The IRL Pittsburgh Dirty Dozen operates similarly. Each group has a ride leader that guides the ride. When we get to one the Dirty Dozen climbs, it’s all out warfare to the top. We all wait and regroup and mosy on to the next climb together. I see where the fence has it’s place and where other rides could benefit from not having it.

      0
      Reply
      Andrew Hunter
      Andrew Hunter
      3 years ago

      It’s been an interesting period without the fence. My basic observation is that for slower D cat group rides, without a fence the field will split. But for faster rides, either driven by higher cat such as C and above or just pan flat routes, then actually the group seems to stick together well. Simply because it takes a lot more effort to break free. Anyway, since I’m a big fan of the social big group D rides such as the Vikings Fatburn rides, I can’t wait for the fence to return.

      3
      Reply
      Nick Humby
      Member
      Nick Humby(@nickhumby)
      3 years ago

      The sprintpalooza ride is awesome, sorry I couldn’t make it this morning but it clashed with Watopia Stage 2. I pretty much stopped doing group rides on Zwift because of some riders getting militant about flyers. Endless ranting about kicking flyers off the ride, telling them to slow down, telling them they are antisocial and much much worse is just unpleasant, unnecessary and it is that ranting which the spoils the group rides and not the flyers themselves imho.

      -3
      Reply
      Sage Koh
      Sage Koh
      3 years ago
      Reply to  Nick Humby

      Flyers should just find faster rides. I dont understand why they cant. Because they are actually too slow to ride in a faster group? Flyers lack consideration or respect for fellow Zwifters and ride leaders. Would you brag about scoring 5 goals in a pee wee hockey game? Would you instagram dunking on an 11 yr old kid in pick up basketball? I feel it’s kinda of the same thing. Just ride in the fricken posted wpk. OR MAN UP AND FIND A FASTER RIDE. It’s cowardly to blow up a social ride.

      7
      Reply
      Joel
      Joel
      3 years ago
      Reply to  Sage Koh

      Gave me an interesting idea! What if instead of drop from Zwift it just bumped you up to the next category? Hmmm…so say you enter as a D group. Then if you ride past the fence for a specific distance…then you get bumped into the C category (along with a message that lets you know)….Could also have a clean up fence…So that if you drop off too far on a C ride then you are regrouped with a D level ride. Not sure how hard the programming would be…

      0
      Reply
      Nita
      Nita
      2 years ago
      Reply to  Sage Koh

      well said. Amen to that.

      0
      Reply
      Marco Vieira
      Marco Vieira(@markelhas)
      3 years ago

      Just glade that is gone, and sad that it will return.

      -4
      Reply
      Stephen
      Stephen
      3 years ago

      I’ve been booted off a ride on a couple of occasions when I have been clearly behind the fence but would still like to see it in place once the issues have been rectified!!

      1
      Reply
      Wes Salmon Zwift HQ
      Super Member
      Wes Salmon Zwift HQ(@wes)
      3 years ago
      Reply to  Stephen

      This is what we’re hoping to resolve for sure Stephen. Certainly no fun to be removed from an event when you’re riding it “right”.

      8
      Reply
      craig
      craig(@cwiley)
      3 years ago

      Love the idea that instead of the fence, elastic banding is used on the front. Get more than x seconds ahead and rolling/air resistance will start increasingly exponentially the further ahead you go. Once in that situation a button would pop up asking if you want to leave the group.

      Feels like a more natural consequence. Ideally the time off the front and aggressiveness of the resistance curve would both be leader choice.

      18
      Reply
      Sage Koh
      Sage Koh
      3 years ago
      Reply to  craig

      That elastic band idea is a great idea for sure.

      0
      Reply
      Rich Lovelock
      Rich Lovelock
      3 years ago
      Reply to  craig

      This is a good idea and something I imagine Zwift could implement without too much fuss by borrowing some logic from the group workout stuff.

      0
      Reply
      Patrick Riley
      Patrick Riley(@yo-pat142)
      3 years ago

      I am nearly 81 and I regularly ride with the group rides I think the fence should come back for these rides as it does split up the riders and spoils the point of a group ride.

      7
      Reply
      Tim
      Tim
      3 years ago

      Agree…keep the fence. Agree 100% with Eric and others…

      5
      Reply
      Bill Aslin
      Bill Aslin
      3 years ago

      As someone that primarily sweeps on group rides, I never see the fence and wish those that want more effort would drop and help riders struggling off the back. Fliers will be fliers, I just sympathize with newer riders that get suckered into chasing them and have an awful group ride experience. Join a group ride = pace with the Yellow Beacon/Leader.

      9
      Reply
      Marjan66
      Marjan66
      3 years ago

      I miss the fence enormously. Riders take off from the start, making it a race. The fence keeps the group together. Please return the fence.

      5
      Reply
      Russell
      Russell
      3 years ago

      I love the fence. I feel like there is a real skill to staying at the right pace and keeping yourself in the peloton. Makes it feel more like a real outdoor group ride where you are constantly changing your power to stay within the group. Much more engaging and fun then rides without the fence which to me feel more like a time trial then a group ride.

      If you want to ride off the front then just ride solo. Why bother signing up for an event?

      5
      Reply
      Dan
      Dan
      3 years ago

      I much prefer events that the don’t use a fence. I think the problem is that many people seem a little too fragile, and should harden up physically and mentally. In my opinion, when everyone rides too clinically, it sucks the fluidity and spontaneity out of the sport. For me, a ride with a fence scarifies passion and beauty for abstract, bloodless numbers.

      -26
      Reply
      tempocyclist.com
      tempocyclist.com
      3 years ago
      Reply to  Dan

      @Dan – Sitting indoors on a turbo staring at animations on a screen is what sacrifices passion and beauty for abstract, bloodless numbers! 😂

      I hated the fence at first, but certain virtual group rides do benefit from it.

      8
      Reply
      Dan
      Dan
      3 years ago
      Reply to  tempocyclist.com

      Here the thing – the pace is never going to be exact for everyone because of weight differences and the terrain. If it’s a small group and is disruptive, that’s one thing. Same thing if people are playing cat and mouse. But if a few people are feeling a little stronger and want to ride together and pull others around I don’t see the problem. Everyone should ride with more conviction, particularly the beacons. Just hit the advertised numbers and if people want to follow they will, and if they don’t they won’t. But I think sometimes beacons get upset… Read more »

      -8
      Reply
      Lou Babal
      Lou Babal
      3 years ago
      Reply to  Dan

      When you are 65 and your best riding years are behind you, when your back is arthritic and your hips don’t quite work without hurting, and you are trying to stay with a D ride that is 15% over advertised w/kg, I hope some asshole comes up to you and just says “harden up”.

      37
      Reply
      Dan
      Dan
      3 years ago
      Reply to  Lou Babal

      Okay boomer.

      -22
      Reply
      J.Richey
      J.Richey
      3 years ago
      Reply to  Lou Babal

      Join us Thursday evening (US), Slowtwitchindoors Hilly Vanilli Chase D group.
      Pace 2.0 – 2.5 W/Kg.
      If the D group ride leader does not maintain the listed pace, call him out on it because he would like to know.

      1
      Reply
      Jack
      Jack
      3 years ago
      Reply to  Dan

      Then you need to race period.

      3
      Reply
      Jhsvdm
      Jhsvdm
      3 years ago
      Reply to  Dan

      Rather enter a race then. Group rides have an advertised pace. Someone for whom that pace may be challenging or maybe what he feels is what he needs after whatever he did the previous day then enters for a group ride which is more social than solo and easier (supposed) than a race or interval training session. Then it becomes a race. The fence should prevent that

      3
      Reply
      Lou Babal
      Lou Babal
      3 years ago

      Every 5 km you get a ticket if within X seconds of the beacon or behind, and then a random ticket is drawn (all this is just automatic within the software) and the winner gets a free month of Zwift. At year end a ticket is drawn for a free lifetime of Zwift.

      1
      Reply
      Paul R
      Paul R(@paulrayner)
      3 years ago

      I don’t understand; if you don’t like the fence, isn’t it just a simple matter of avoiding those rides which use a fence?
      So far on Zwift, I haven’t been tempted by fixed pace group rides because I like the flexibility to go at my own pace. Why on earth would you sign up for a fixed pace ride and then want to ride at a different pace!?

      19
      Reply
      Edward Krasnai
      Edward Krasnai
      3 years ago
      Reply to  Paul R

      exactly! Don’t join the ride if you don’t like the pace. There are plenty of races and one can ride solo at whatever pace they like.

      2
      Reply
      Rich Lovelock
      Rich Lovelock
      3 years ago
      Reply to  Paul R

      I don’t really understand the logic either! Maybe some simply can’t help their competitive spirit winning out. Perhaps also it’s herd mentality, if a small group around goes ahead, it’s perhaps easy to get sucked in without prompts and awareness of the beacon position. It does take focus and concentration to stay with the beacon, I think the fence takes this cognitive load away and is generally an asset to rides, at the compromise of removing a little of the spontaneous/natural feel.

      0
      Reply
      Gareth Rogers
      Gareth Rogers
      3 years ago

      If the fence is an option to the organizer and it’s advertised in the event whether a group ride is fenced/no fence, where’s the problem? Don’t like a fence, don’t sign up for fenced group rides. Simple. Myself, i like a fenced group ride. When I want to race, I enter a race.

      12
      Reply
      Keith
      Keith(@keith7747)
      3 years ago

      Keep the fence.

      7
      Reply
      EndUser
      EndUser
      3 years ago

      I am a Cat C on zp so I do Group C events even when I running at the pace I still find myself out ahead on group rides at times I guess depending on the course type.. Done with and without the fence I find it plenty enjoyable …

      There just no satisfying everyone … I suppose hide the position counters so they cannot get a screenshot of them being number 1 in a group ride of 200

      😆

      0
      Reply
      Rueban Balasubramaniam
      Rueban Balasubramaniam
      3 years ago

      In my experience, many riders lack the ability to exercise intensity discipline. It’s not difficult to sit within a w/per kilo range. Even when climbing you just ride up slower rather than pushing the watts unless this is the predetermined expectation to go harder. For me, Zwift group rides make lousy endurance or tempo rides because of this indiscipline. But they work well for threshold or race simulation. However, the lack of discipline makes them generally irksome. In short: bring back the fence!

      2
      Reply
      Carl J
      Carl J(@runbikebbq)
      3 years ago

      “In certain situations and conditions, a non-trivial number of users were being removed from events, even though they were well behind the fence or the leader.”

      A couple of weeks ago, I was well behind the leader, so far back, that they ended up lapping me (think I started late). And lo and behold, when the leader caught up to me, there was the fence, and I started getting the warnings

      0
      Reply
      mike wepplo
      mike wepplo
      3 years ago

      simple, bring back the fence and let the ride leaders decide if they want to use it or not and let the riders choose to ride in groups that use or do not use it as they want, choice is what we want

      4
      Reply
      Dan Jewell
      Dan Jewell
      3 years ago

      Miss the fence.

      2
      Reply
      Howard Welch
      Howard Welch
      3 years ago

      I appreciate the ride leaders, and will go with their judgement. It is good to have a marker of where the leader is thinking the group should be.

      1
      Reply
      Robert Walker
      Robert Walker
      3 years ago

      Why not have the fence as an option for the ride leader? People that want the fence will go on a ride that has a fence, and vice versa for no fence.

      1
      Reply
      Eric Schlange
      Author
      Top Member
      Eric Schlange(@eschlange)
      3 years ago
      Reply to  Robert Walker

      The fence IS an option. It’s configured when the event is set up by Zwift, along with various other parameters like route, ride length, drafting type, etc, etc.

      Plus the leader can always just leave it off, even if the fence is enabled. So leaders definitely have control over fence usage!

      3
      Reply
      Michael Witzel
      Michael Witzel
      3 years ago

      I don’t need the fence.

      -7
      Reply
      Barrie Collins
      Trusted Member
      Barrie Collins(@barrie)
      3 years ago
      Reply to  Michael Witzel

      It’s not about what you need although that’s great. There are a number of reasons why a fence can be useful, but to me it seems one significant benefit is to newer, older, or weaker riders who get to share in a community ride without being left behind by half the peloton.

      0
      Reply
      Ed Krasnai
      Ed Krasnai
      3 years ago
      Reply to  Barrie Collins

      or for people who want to ride long base miles in a set range with others.

      0
      Reply
      Carl Demola
      Carl Demola(@carl-demola911)
      3 years ago

      I think the fence is a great idea. At first i was all against it , but my wife needed it and i supported her. We have 2 set-ups and i would join so she has a wheel. I always enter a event to race. There r times when i want to do a recovery with a group and the fence is nice. Thank you very much for letting me put my input in.

      4
      Reply
      David M
      David M
      3 years ago

      Bring the fence back.. every group ride that I have participated in as been way beyond the adversities watts and the entire group is shattered from the start… it’s ridiculous. .

      8
      Reply
      Scott
      Scott
      3 years ago

      I tried leading a couple of group rides before the fence. I rode at the advertised w/kg, flyers went off the front, I asked to slow to advertised pace, was ignored. I ended up increasing speed to keep in the 50th percentile, this caused people at the back to be dropped even more. In the end it seemed like it would be impossible to keep everyone happy. In the end I stopped leading events. I think the fence would help, although I wish it added weight/resistance instead of kicking riders out….or even better, I wish it took 1 w/kg and… Read more »

      1
      Reply
      bill combs
      bill combs
      3 years ago

      Keep the fence. Flyers are no good for group rides, even though they seem to be the ones who don’t like the fence.

      4
      Reply
      Shawn Schmitz
      Super Member
      Shawn Schmitz(@beachgrad05)
      3 years ago

      Yesterday I did Hive group ride advertised at 1.5w/kg. My FTP currently is 1.74w/kg. I was not at 1.5 yet found myself off front often and having to ride slower to return to group. My avg w/kg for ride was 1.25. I don’t have firm grasp of how w/kg is used to keep folks together.

      0
      Reply
      Eric Schlange
      Author
      Top Member
      Eric Schlange(@eschlange)
      3 years ago
      Reply to  Shawn Schmitz

      Depends on your weight. On a flat route, if you’re heavier… your 1.25 may be a lot more watts than the leader’s 1.5.

      0
      Reply
      Claude
      Claude
      3 years ago

      Without the fence I find myself working harder not to get dropped, an instinct developed from 35 years of cat. 3 racing, rather than maintaining a group ride advertised level. Bring back the fence. If I want to go all out and keep up, there are categorized races.

      1
      Reply
      Stu
      Stu
      3 years ago

      I think the fence is essential for ANY group ride under 3.0w/kg, with the possible exception of large group event rides where the in game experience deteriorates with too many Zwifters occupying the same inch of road (FPS issues, messy visual etc) If a stronger rider wants to participate in a lower group, then they should show respect and stay under limits. Perhaps if it’s a club ride like DIRT and you just want to support your fellow members then put your hand up to sweep. It’s a waaayy more satisfying feeling to have someone thank you for lending them… Read more »

      1
      Reply
      Paul Eddy
      Paul Eddy
      3 years ago

      The fence is needed for some group rides, especially when they advertise a specific w/kg, either average or range. Some riders mistakenly believe that a 2.0 – 2.5 w/kg ride is a 2.5 w/kg avg. Not so. Especially if it has a sprint area, like London. Just for numbers, say a ride is a 2.0 w/kg avg. The sprint is 3.5 w/kg. Those who elect not to sprint can never catch back on because the front has to free wheel at .5 w/kg for the same sprint duration to get back to the average. Which, of course, never happens. As… Read more »

      0
      Reply
      Ron Gallo
      Member
      Ron Gallo(@rgallo1964)
      3 years ago

      I think I miss the fence but I miss rider’s common sense more! You see a ride posted as a ‘C’ group ride, you should expect to be a little bit easier for you if you are a ‘B’ or even an ‘A’ rider. So it only makes sense that you shouldn’t sign up for that ride unless you are disciplined enough to ride sub threshold or even recovery level. My next comment will upset those that are disciplined enough to go for a recovery ride in a lower cat group. If Zwift can prevent me from entering a women’s… Read more »

      -1
      Reply
      Tridoc
      Tridoc
      3 years ago

      yep very happy the fence has gone – hated it

      -2
      Reply
      M Brown
      M Brown
      3 years ago

      From my experience the fence isn’t all that. You end up with two separate groups, fence huggers and those with the leader at 10 seconds. Plus snakes seem more common with the fence than the blob we’re all aiming for. Before the fence, fliers would go off, and the rest of us got on with the ride. With the fence, the subtle skills of pace management seem to have been lost and now the fence has been turned off, the group rides are worse than they were before the fence was implemented. Also, I find ride leaders are often not… Read more »

      -1
      Reply
      Eric Schlange
      Author
      Top Member
      Eric Schlange(@eschlange)
      3 years ago
      Reply to  M Brown

      The “two groups” phenomenon can definitely happen–I’ve had that happen when leading myself! The way to solve that is to pull the fence in to 5s. It’s tough, because you don’t want the fence so close that the group can’t stretch out a bit… but you don’t want it to far away that you end up with multiple groups.

      As for ride leaders – yeah, that happens sometimes too. A separate but related issue!

      1
      Reply
      Russell
      Russell
      3 years ago

      For me, if the ride says its about riding together then thats that, the discipline of keeping the group together is something the riders should respect
      If riders want to split the group up, why do they ride in an event that says its a group ride??
      Keep the fence to keep the discipline
      Of you want to form a breakaway, join a race!

      1
      Reply
      John Burgess
      John Burgess
      3 years ago

      The problem with the fence is it’s linked to the ride leader , I see many times leaders moving up and down the group so the fence moves too.

      2
      Reply
      Ani
      Ani
      3 years ago

      I think the fence is useful keeps us together and should be used

      2
      Reply
      Ami
      Ami
      3 years ago

      I think till fence is back we should ride behind the group leader

      1
      Reply
      wpdiscuz   wpDiscuz

      Free Zwift Trial

      Create Account

      Newest Featured Posts

      Introducing the FastChain Aesthete

      Trainers

      Training Log: Build Me Up, Week 1

      Training & Nutrition

      How to Unlock the 100kph Achievement Badge in Zwift

      How Zwift Works

      Support This Site

      Contribute a post, shop through us, make a donation, advertise on this site. See how you can support Zwift Insider!

      NEWSLETTER SIGNUP

      Receive a summary of Zwift tips and news every 2 weeks! Click to subscribe.

      This community-driven site is maintained by Eric Schlange and a team of Zwift enthusiasts. Zwift Insider is independent of Zwift corporate (www.zwift.com), although Zwift does provide funding to help defray site costs.

      This site contains affiliate links to Amazon, Wahoo, and other brands. Zwift Insider makes a small commission on purchases made from these links, so please shop through them to support our efforts.

      Terms of Use/DMCA Copyright Policy

      Privacy Policy

      [email protected]

      Latest articles

      Introducing the FastChain Aesthete

      Training Log: Build Me Up, Week 1

      Notable Zwift Events for the Weekend of March 25-26

      Popular Categories

      • Racing1010
      • News741
      • Training & Nutrition586
      • Events536
      • Interviews443
      • Routes & Maps312
      148
      0
      Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
      ()
      x
      | Reply
      Comment Author Info
      :wpds_smile::wpds_grin::wpds_wink::wpds_mrgreen::wpds_neutral::wpds_twisted::wpds_arrow::wpds_shock::wpds_unamused::wpds_cool::wpds_evil::wpds_oops::wpds_razz::wpds_roll::wpds_cry::wpds_eek::wpds_lol::wpds_mad::wpds_sad::wpds_exclamation::wpds_question::wpds_idea::wpds_hmm::wpds_beg::wpds_whew::wpds_chuckle::wpds_silly::wpds_envy::wpds_shutmouth:
      ‹ Back to Categories
      You are going to send email to

      Move Comment

    • Related Posts